‘The Challenge: All Stars’: Beth on Returning After Quitting & Leroy on That ‘Dirty’ Move

The Challenge: All Stars is back with a fan-favorite twist! For Season 5, the Rivals theme returns, with players being paired up alongside their biggest rivals. For some of the pairings, the rivalry is personal, and for others, the tension comes strictly from past gameplay. For Beth Stolarczyk, the rivalry with Jonna Mannion cuts deep after Beth previously accused her partner of cheating on her husband with Mj Garrett. Meanwhile, Leroy Garrett betrayed Devin Walker on The Challenge: Double Agents by orchestrating a move that sent him home. TV Insider caught up with Beth and Leroy about their rivalries and more ahead of the season premiere. Can we hop back to Season 40 quickly? Leroy, what was with giving [Johnny] Bananas one karma point? The fans need to know. Leroy Garrett: When I got eliminated, it was the very first elimination. When I hugged Bananas goodbye, he was like, “Leroy, I’m going to be right behind you.