All’s Fair Cast: Where Have You Seen The Stars Before?

Often, when something’s said to have had “mixed reviews” it’s a polite way of saying that it’s, to be frank, a bit of a stinker.

But in the case of Ryan Murphy’s new legal drama All’s Fair, the reviews have been overwhelmingly bad with no room for any ambiguity, as critics have savaged it for being “fascinatingly, existentially terrible” while it holds a 0% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

That being said, human nature means plenty of us will be heading straight to watch All’s Fair on that basis alone.

If that’s the case, here’s where you might recognise the star-studded cast from…

Come on, she’s Kim Kardashian isn’t she? Willingly or not, you’ll be aware of Paris Hilton’s childhood BFF/employee’s rise to fame through Keeping Up With The Kardashians along with her mum Kris Jenner and siblings Kourtney, Khloe, Kendall, Kylie and Rob.

Kim built on her reality TV fame to become a tabloid staple, as well as a beauty and fashion entrepreneur through ventures like her shapewear brand Skims. as well as dipping her toe in the legal field long before All’s Fair on-screen interpretation.

She’s also no stranger to the small screen, having previously teamed up with Ryan Murphy to appear in the 12th season of American Horror Story. She’s also popped up in the likes of Disaster Movie, 2 Broke Girls and a number of her ex-husband Ye’s (FKA Kanye West) music videos.

Screen legend Sarah Paulson is no stranger to All’s Fair creator Ryan Murphy, and has been a regular fixture in his iconic series American Horror Story, as well as Ratched, Feud and the American Crime Story seasons The People v. O. J. Simpson (which earned her an Emmy Award for her role as prosecutor Marcia Clark) and Impeachment.

Outside of the Murphy-verse, Sarah’s TV work spans 30 years, starting with 90s horror series American Gothic and also including Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, Desperate Housewives, Deadwood, Cupid, Mrs. America, and The Bear.

As for her big screen work, you might have seen Sarah in the Netflix thrillers Run or Bird Box, as well as historical romance Carol, the hard-hitting drama 12 Years A Slave, the ill-fated film adaptation of The Goldfinch or the all-female Ocean’s 8 reboot.

Niecy Nash-Betts has also worked with Ryan Murphy before, appearing in Scream Queens and Grotesquerie, as well as his controversial Netflix series Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story as the serial killer’s suspicious neighbour, Glenda Cleveland, even picking up an Emmy for her performance.

Before all that, Niecy’s major breakthrough was in early 2000s comedy series Reno 911! while she also presented the home makeover show Clean House for seven years.

More Emmy recognition came with her depiction of Didi in the US version of Getting On, as well as her role as Delores Wise in 2019 miniseries When They See Us, which depicted the 1989 Central Park jogger case and wrongful conviction of five Black and Latino men for the sexual assault.

You might have also seen Niecy in the 2014 Oscar-nominated historical drama film Selma, where she portrayed civil rights activist Richie Jean Jackson in the story of the Selma to Montgomery marches.

Before transforming into divorce lawyer Liberty Ronson in All’s Fair, Naomi has a long career in both TV and film. Her major breakthrough was in David Lynch’s 2001 mystery film Mulholland Drive, which is often cited as one of the greatest films of all time.

Naomi went on to star in critically acclaimed films like 21 Grams and The Impossible, which earned her Best Actress Oscars nominations, as well as blockbusters like King Kong and the Divergent franchise.

Her other film work includes the divisive biopic Diana, the unsettling Funny Games or the Oscar-winning Birdman.

You’ll probably have seen Naomi on your TV screen at some point too, with the actor most recently starring in Lena Dunham’s buzzy Netflix series Too Much opposite Richard E. Grant. She’s also been in Netflix thriller The Watcher as well as US miniseries The Loudest Voice, Gypsy, Twin Peaks: The Return and Sleepwalkers.

Oh, and let’s not forget her stint as Julie Gibson in Home And Away back in 1991.

Teyana Taylor – who plays All Fair’s trainee lawyer Milan – actually started her career in the music industry after choreographing Beyoncé’s 2006 Ring The Alarm music video and collaborating with Ye on the rapper’s acclaimed My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy and The Life Of Pablo albums.

So far, 2025 has been a massive year for Teyana, after starring opposite Leonardo DiCaprio in Paul Thomas Anderson’s action thriller One Battle After Another, but she made her acting debut well before this year.

Glenn Close is an undeniable screen icon, famously holding the record for the living actor who has been nominated for the most Oscars without a win.

Her most notable work has included the erotic thriller Fatal Attraction, the period romance Dangerous Liaisons, the family drama The Wife, Disney’s live-action remake of 101 Dalmatians and the 1990 film adaptation of Hamlet.

More recently, she’s appeared in Netflix projects Hillbilly Elegy (based on the memoir by future vice president JD Vance) and Lee Daniels’ horror The Deliverance.

You’ve also probably seen Glenn in TV projects including Damages and The Shield, while her work on stage has earned her three Tonys, including for the musical Sunset Boulevard.

The on-screen husband of Kim Kardashian in All’s Fair, Matthew Noszka was better known as a model for brands like Calvin Klein, Nike and Levi’s before making the move into acting.

He previously had a role in Lee Daniels’ series Star, the Christmas rom-com Let It Snow, the revenge thriller Perfect Addiction and the polarising Jennifer Lawrence outing No Hard Feelings.

Initially starting out as a theatre actor, Judith Light had her breakthrough in the US soap One Life To Live, for which she won two Daytime Emmys.

As her career progressed, she won over a new legion of fans as Claire Meade in Ugly Betty and Shelly Pfefferman in Transparent, both of which earned her recognition at the Emmys.

Like many of the cast, All’s Fair isn’t Judith’s first time working with Ryan Murphy, having previously appeared in the second and third seasons of American Crime Story, The Politician and a harrowing episode of American Horror Stories.

She also picked up another Emmy for her work in the Rian Johnson series Poker Face, while her movie work has included The Menu, Hot Air and the musical Tick, Tick, Boom…!.

An established theatre star, fans of Ryan Murphy’s work will no doubt know Grace Gummer for her recurring role in the fourth season of American Horror Story, subtitled Freak Show, and previously shared the screen with Kim Kardashian in the anthology series’ most recent outing, Delicate.

She has also been a regular fixture on the TV series Mr Robot, The Newsroom and Extant.

If you’re getting déjà vu over Kate Berlant, it’s probably because you just watched her in the second season of the Netflix rom-com series Nobody Wants This.

As well as her work as a popular standup, Kate has also appeared in movies like Don’t Worry Darling, Sorry To Bother You and Dream Scenario, as well as the Netflix sketch series The Characters.

She’s also had stand-out roles in the TV comedies Search Party, The Other Two and The Good Place.

In the late 80s, Ed O’Neill made a name for herself as father figure Al Bundy in Married With Children, before winning over a new generation as a very different patriarch, Jay Pritchett, in Modern Family.

His other notable work includes the big-screen comedy Wayne’s World, the crime thriller The Bone Collector or the sports biopic Prefontaine.

The Handmaid’s Tale viewers will recognise the British actor for his role as Luke, the on-screen husband of Elisabeth Moss, for which he was nominated for an Emmy.

As well as All’ Fair, O-T’s other stand-out work has included two episodes of Doctor Who, Marvel’s Black Widow, the romantic drama Looking and the Apple TV+ comedy Loot.

He also played Barack Obama opposite Viola Davis’ Michelle in the TV drama The First Lady.

Three episodes of All’s Fair are now streaming on Disney+, with new instalments following every Tuesday.