Bailey Zimmerman’s ‘Different Night Same Rodeo’: All 18 Tracks Ranked

Bailey Zimmerman is enjoying a tremendous ascent as a rising country star, but as he frequently reminds us on Different Night Same Rodeo, which arrived Friday (Aug. 8), he’s not so lucky when it comes to love.

More from Billboard

Cold-hearted women and nostalgic memories of the ones that got away — and they almost all did — are themes throughout the 18-track album, issued on Atlantic Records/Warner Music Nashville. The heartache is palpable, and Zimmerman brings a rugged, appealing vulnerability to many of the songs here.

Not all is woe, though: Zimmerman is unabashedly and unapologetically romantically and happily in love on “Before You,” and there’s a fun — albeit through lightheartedly gritted-teeth — resilience to staying with his partner on “Everything But Up.”

The best songs, such as “Backup Plan” with Luke Combs and “Comin’ in Cold” have a stomp that shows off both Zimmerman’s country twang and rock bravado. Though the album as a whole could use some more up-tempo tracks, he’s at ease with both fast and slow songs and can comfortably toggle back and forth in service of the song.

In addition to Combs, the gritty-voiced Zimmerman has some choice collaborators on the set — Diplo, The Kid LAROI and McKenzie Porter. (His Billboard Hot 100 top five duet with BigXThaPlug “All the Way” will appear on BigX’s upcoming country set and is absent here.)

Zimmerman, who co-wrote seven tracks on the album, teams again with producer Austin Shawn, whose crisp production brings the tracks to life, as does standout musicianship from fiddle player Jenee Fleenor, steel guitarist Scotty Sanders and banjoist Tim Galloway. The album is chockful of strong lyrical lines, even if the full songs don’t always live up to their individual parts.

The Illinois native shows strong growth following 2023 Religiously: The Album and such hits as “Fall in Love” and  “Rock and a Hard Place.” It’s hard to believe that less than five years ago he was working blue-collar jobs. It’s safe to say those days are long past him.

Below is an early take on the best songs off the long-awaited set.

18. “Dare You To Try It”

Cliched tale as boy throws down the gauntlet to convince girl to take a chance, despite everything she’s heard about boys like him. In an album that has some truly clever lines, this one takes the easy way out; for example, using the line “Girl I double dog you…” instead of finding a way to use the actual saying, “Girl, I double dog dare you.”

17. “New To Country”

Sturdy, feisty country rock song defying anyone who wants to claim Zimmerman hasn’t earned his country bonafides. You can say what you want about him except he’s “new to country.”  Zimmerman’s current headlining tour takes its title from this track.

16. “It’s All Good”

Mid-tempo shuffler with nice steel guitar work by Scotty Sanders takes the overused phrase “It’s All Good” as the base for a relationship that is all good “until it ain’t.” Zimmerman examines making the same mistakes over and over again until he realizes it’s all downhill and there’s no sense in trying to move into reverse.  It’s a “new day but the same old song, so why the hell do we keep singing along,” Zimmerman asks.

15. “When It Was”

For someone who’s only 26, Zimmerman has a strong streak of nostalgia that runs through many songs on the album, including this thumping ode to a past love. He remembers all too well when it was his songs she sang along to and his hand she held, but those days are gone.

14. “Holding On”

Mid-tempo, guitar-driven ballad about surviving the tough times in a relationship. Zimmerman provocatively asks, “If this was your last breath, would you waste it on me?” Are he and his partner meant to last? The jury is still out by the time the song ends.

13. “Chevy Silverado”

A Chevy Silverado is the truck of choice in country songs of late and Zimmerman still has the truck, but the girl is long gone in this mid-tempo, sloping track that is one of the album’s most autobiographical.  The rhyme scheme—he rhymes “Silverado” with “heartbroke desperado”— may remind some of Morgan Wallen’s superior “Sand In My Boots.”

12. “These Nights” (feat. Mackenzie Carpenter)

On this genial guitar-strumming duet with Mackenzie Carpenter, Zimmerman has turned the corner on lost love. The nights of tossing and turning are over. He may not be ready to love again, but he’s moving on “as I lay me down to sleep/memories of you I won’t keep.”

11. “Happy Ever After Me”

On the album’s mid-tempo closing track, Zimmerman, similarly to on “Fall in Love,” sings about a love who has found her happily ever after once she has moved on. It’s a fractured fairy tale for Zimmerman, who looks back on “once upon a good time,” but sees that this Cinderella found her Prince Charming and glass slipper only after leaving him.

10. “Yours For The Breaking”

Regrets, Zimmerman has a few, and as the love he thought would last a lifetime says goodbye, he tells her she might as well take his heart because he’s not going to need it anymore in this slow roll of a ballad.

9. “Holy Smokes”

“I was only scared of the devil and her dad” is a great first line, as Zimmerman recalls the innocent rush of love in in the church parking lot. Lots of firsts were happening- between cigarettes and romance—and sinning felt damn heavenly in this mid-tempo winner.

8. “Before You”

Straight up love song and one of the most traditionally country songs on the album. Zimmerman is unabashedly showing his appreciation to the lover who has turned his life around. She’s taken him from lonely to loved, lost to found, and now there’s nothing he won’t do to be the best man he can be for her. Cue the waving, illuminated cell phones in concert.

7. “Hell or High Water”

The track, which originally appeared on last summer’s Twisters soundtrack is a yearning song written by Ashley Gorley and Austin Shawn that features an emotional delivery by Zimmerman and nature imagery–dark clouds, hot flames, high water, turning tides–to describe a worsening situation that may or may not be survivable.

6. “Everything But Up”

Zimmerman’s riding high in the saddle in this swinging, galloping track that musically will appeal to fans of Dasha’s “Austin.” The catchy melody and strong instrumentation bolster a song about fidelity and resilience in a relationship. No one’s throwing in the towel here no matter how many stumbles they take because they’re “giving everything but up” and they will be together “until they lay us in the ground.”

5. “Lost” (feat. The Kid LAROI)

The Kid LAROI joins Zimmerman for this infectious high energy, pop bop– credited to seven songwriters– that sounds like something straight out of a Post Malone album. “Lost” should be found at a pop radio station near you. Bolstered by pop punk drums and screaming guitars, the heartbreaker serves as one of the album’s strongest ear worms.

4. “Comin’ In Cold”

Album opener is a slow-to-mid-tempo stomp with stellar fiddle work by the great Jenee Fleenor about a heartbreaker who keeps coming back into his life. The album title comes from a lyric here as he ruefully notes, “different night, same rodeo.”

3. “At The Same Time”

Zimmerman is out of sync with his girlfriend on this tender ballad–the best of the bunch of his woe-is-me tracks on the set. Sad boy Zimmerman and his lover are “sleeping back-to-back as we ain’t even seeing eye-to-eye” while they work their way toward the inevitable parting.

2. “Ashes” (with Diplo)

Rollicking, upbeat track that is, unsurprisingly, ready-made for a night of line dancing with some fun country twists-. The clever twist is they’ve burned each other so much, he questions how the hell they ashes by aren’t now, but they are drawn to each other like a moth to the proverbial flame. Thematically, it treads the same theme as Rodney Crowell’s great 1980 tune “Ashes By Now,” but includes the memorable line, “Both of us are bat sh-t doing bad sh-t”.

1. “Backup Plan” (feat. Luke Combs)

Smoky, stompy duet with Combs that the pair debuted at Stagecoach serves serve as a theme song to both artist’s dogged, driving ambition where failure is not an option. “Getting back up is the only backup plan you need,” they sing with a steely determination. Written originally for Twisters (Zimmerman’s “Hell or High Water” made the soundtrack instead), this feels like a fine, flinty manifesto for anyone who won’t give up the fight. 

Best of Billboard

Sign up for Billboard’s Newsletter. For the latest news, follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.