Sabrina Carpenter Wears Three Halloween Costumes in NYC

Do you want the (dream) house tour? Everyone’s favorite Polly Pocket pop star embraced her Barbie side last night at the final of four Short n’ ~~Sweet~~ Spooky NYC shows. Bringing not one, not two, but three sparkly costumes to the stage, Sabrina Carpenter proved MSG was the place to be this Halloween.

While concertgoers and fans all over the world took the holiday to dress up as Carpenter—with her classic sparkly towel, babydoll dresses, and platform pumps—the star herself opened the show as Wonder Woman. Her first costume of the evening, which featured a gold tiara and red boots, set the stage for a night of Sabrinaween that rivaled last year’s Playboy bunny, Tinkerbell, and Grease’s Sandy costumes.

Surprising fans with a cover of Aqua’s “Barbie Girl,” Carpenter pulled a set straight from Margot Robbie’s on-screen wardrobe. Her bright pink cowgirl vest was embellished with sparkly gemstones and stars, designed with a cropped hem for a midriff-baring style. She paired the top with a matching bandana tied around her neck and coordinating flared trousers, designed with metallic stars and a corset tie. And, with her bouncy blonde curls and white cowboy hat, she brought major country music star energy—for a Barbie meets Dolly Parton crossover.

For the infamous “arrest” moment of the show, Carpenter revealed a new sparkly mini dress—with a Fred Flintstone twist. The bedazzled orange look featured black spots and a blue necktie, and she paired it with chunky black platform pumps with bone accents. For the occasion, she arrested the one and only Drew Barrymore, who looked unrecognizable in a Ghostface costume before whipping it off in a dramatic reveal.