Secret Lives of Mormon Wives stars Whitney Leavitt and Jen Affleck are competing against each other in the 34th season of Dancing With the Stars. But who are the other MomTok stars voting for? Mayci Neely revealed who she has been voting for each week, and the answer might surprise you.
Neely, 30, has been splitting her Dancing With the Stars votes between Leavitt, 32, and Affleck, 26 .
“You guys know me, I vote for both,” Neely said on the Whine Down podcast. “I go evenly. Call me a fence-rider or whatever. But it’s too hard — I want them both to succeed and win.”
It’s a sweet and diplomatic move from Neely, who’s built her fanbase on being fair and empathetic during tense reality TV moments. Both Jen and Whitney are fan favorites this season, which means plenty of viewers can probably relate. It’s hard to choose just one!
‘SLOMW’ Star Doesn’t Want ‘Dancing With the Stars’
While Neely loves cheering from the sidelines, she isn’t necessarily ready to compete in the ballroom. Unlike Vanderpump Rules star Scheana Shay, who has been vocal about wanting to join DWTS for years, Neely says she “wouldn’t be an immediate yes” if the show ever called.
“I legit would be so embarrassed,” she confessed with a laugh. “I would probably have the worst anxiety every week. I would have to get a beta blocker to get through it.”
Still, she wouldn’t completely rule it out.
“Would I say no? Probably not,” she added. “I would say I’m open to it, but it wouldn’t be an immediate yes.”
Neely admits she’s competitive in other ways. She’s played tennis for years and has quick footwork, but she doesn’t consider herself a dancer.
“Even when we do MomTok videos, I’m always in the background,” she said. “I need to learn the dance at least seven days in advance before I can film!”
Watch Dancing With the Stars Tuesday nights at 8 p.m. ET or stream on Hulu.
This story was originally reported by Parade on Oct 18, 2025, where it first appeared in the News section. Add Parade as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
‘ The preceding article may include information circulated by third parties ’
‘ Some details of this article were extracted from the following source www.yahoo.com ’
